Mention the word “trust”, and many people immediately think it must be something for the very wealthy.
Perhaps you picture a family with millions of dollars, complicated businesses and an accountant on speed dial.
But that really isn’t the whole story.
A testamentary trust can be useful for a very ordinary family. You might own your home, have some superannuation, perhaps an investment property or some shares, and have spent most of your working life building up a comfortable financial position.
You may not think of yourself as wealthy at all.
But one day, your children could inherit a very substantial amount from you.
So when you make your Will, there are really two questions to think about:
“Who do I want to leave my assets to?”
“What is the best way for them to receive those assets?”
That second question is where a testamentary trust can be worth considering.
What exactly is a testamentary trust?
It sounds complicated, but the basic idea is quite simple.
A testamentary trust is a trust that you establish in your Will. It does not operate while you are alive. Instead, it takes effect after your death, when your estate is being administered.
Rather than simply saying:
“I leave my estate equally to my children.”
Your Will can give your children the opportunity to receive their inheritance through a trust.
Why might you do that?
Because life changes.
Think about where your children might be in 20 years
This is probably the easiest way to understand the value of a testamentary trust.
Let’s say your daughter is 30.
She has a good job, is happily married, and everything is going well. If you’re making your Will today, you might understandably think:
“Why would she need a trust? I’ll just leave her the money.”
But hopefully your Will won’t be needed for another 20 or 30 years.
By then, she might have children of her own. She might run a business. She might have investments. Her marriage might have broken down. She might have experienced financial difficulties.
Or everything might be going wonderfully.
The point is that none of us knows.
A good estate plan doesn’t try to predict the future. It gives your family useful options when the future arrives.
Can a testamentary trust protect an inheritance?
Most people don’t build an estate overnight.
They spend decades paying a mortgage, putting money into superannuation, investing and saving.
When you look at it that way, it makes sense to ask whether the assets you have worked so hard to accumulate should simply be handed over outright when you die, or whether your children might benefit from having another option.
A properly structured testamentary trust may provide some protection for inherited assets in circumstances involving creditors, legal claims, or other financial difficulties.
It is not a magic shield, and it is important not to suggest that it is. The effectiveness of a trust will always depend on its terms and the particular circumstances.
If you’ve spent a lifetime building an inheritance for your family, it is worth thinking about how that inheritance might be protected once they receive it.
What if my child’s marriage breaks down?
This is something parents ask us about a lot.
It is usually not because they dislike their son-in-law or daughter-in-law.
They simply think:
“I’ve worked all my life for this. If something goes wrong in my child’s relationship in the future, I’d like as much of my estate as possible to remain available for my child and grandchildren.”
That is a perfectly understandable concern.
A testamentary trust can be relevant to that planning.
But we need to add an important word of caution.
No structure simply guarantees an inheritance will be ignored in a future family law property settlement. Much will depend on the circumstances at the time, including how the trust was structured, who controls it and how its assets have been used.
So we don’t suggest testamentary trusts as some clever way of “beating” the Family Court.
We look at them as part of sensible, long-term estate planning.
It isn’t necessarily about controlling your children
Another concern we sometimes hear is:
“I trust my children. I don’t want to control their money after I’m gone.”
Neither do we.
For young or vulnerable beneficiaries, there certainly can be good reasons to have someone else manage an inheritance. But an adult child’s testamentary trust can have a very different purpose.
Rather than taking choices away from them, the idea can be to give them more choices.
If circumstances permit, they may have the flexibility to retain inherited assets within the trust rather than having everything transferred immediately into their personal name.
That means we’re not necessarily saying:
“I don’t trust my children with their inheritance.”
We’re saying:
“I trust my children, so I want to leave them an inheritance with useful options attached to it.”
That’s a very different way of looking at it.
What are the tax benefits of a testamentary trust?
Tax is often the part that gets everyone’s attention.
Testamentary trusts can have taxation advantages in appropriate circumstances.
There has also been understandable concern about changes to the tax treatment of trusts and, in particular, rules affecting the tax treatment of certain income associated with testamentary trusts.
That can leave people wondering:
“If the tax rules have changed, is there still any point having one?”
We think that asks the wrong question.
Tax should be one consideration, not the entire reason you establish a testamentary trust.
A trust may still provide value through:
greater flexibility for your children;
potential asset protection;
planning for children and grandchildren;
protecting younger or vulnerable beneficiaries;
managing investments over time; and
helping preserve family assets for the next generation.
So we wouldn’t recommend putting a testamentary trust into a Will just because somebody told you it would “save tax”.
But equally, we wouldn’t dismiss a testamentary trust just because the tax rules have changed.
The better question is whether the structure makes sense for your family as a whole.
Isn’t all of this going to be complicated?
There is a little more administration involved once a testamentary trust is operating. Depending on the circumstances, there can be accounting, taxation and record-keeping requirements.
So no, a testamentary trust isn’t right for everybody.
But there is one point that often makes people feel much more comfortable about them.
You don’t have to run the trust now.
You aren’t opening another bank account tomorrow. You aren’t lodging another tax return next year simply because your Will contains a testamentary trust.
The provisions sit in your Will, and the trust only comes into operation after your death.
That’s a really important distinction.
The question isn’t whether you want the inconvenience of administering another trust.
It is whether giving your family the option of a trust in the future could be worthwhile.
You probably don’t need to be as wealthy as you think
This brings us back to where we started.
You don’t need a huge share portfolio or a family business to have an estate worth protecting.
For many families, the family home alone can represent a significant asset. Add superannuation, investments and savings accumulated over a lifetime, and the amount ultimately passing to the next generation can be considerable.
That’s why we don’t think testamentary trusts should automatically be put into the “I’m not wealthy enough for that” basket.
They are worth discussing if you:
own your home or an investment property;
are likely to leave a meaningful inheritance to your children;
have children with young families of their own;
have a child who owns a business or faces financial risk;
worry about what might happen if a child’s relationship breaks down;
have a young or vulnerable beneficiary; or
simply want to give your family greater flexibility with their inheritance.
A good Will isn’t just about who gets what
When people sit down to make a Will, the natural starting point is:
“Everything to my spouse, then to my children.”
And sometimes that is exactly the right answer.
But making a Will is an opportunity to think a little further ahead.
You’ve worked hard for what you have.
So rather than asking:
“Am I wealthy enough to need a testamentary trust?”
perhaps ask:
“Would giving my family this option make their inheritance more useful, flexible or protected?”
If the answer might be yes, then it is worth having the conversation.
Frequently asked questions about testamentary trusts
What is a testamentary trust?
A testamentary trust is a trust established by a Will that comes into operation after the Will-maker dies.
Are testamentary trusts only for wealthy families?
No. They can be worth considering whenever a person expects to leave a meaningful inheritance and wants to give their beneficiaries additional flexibility or protection.
Can a testamentary trust protect an inheritance from divorce?
A testamentary trust may help protect inherited wealth, but it does not guarantee that assets will be excluded from a future family law property settlement. Your existing material already raises relationship breakdown as one potential asset-protection consideration.
Do testamentary trusts have tax benefits?
They can have taxation advantages in certain circumstances, but tax should not be the sole reason for including one in a Will.
When does a testamentary trust start?
The provisions are included in the Will, but the trust does not come into effect during the Will-maker's lifetime.
Do I need a lawyer to create a testamentary trust?
Given the legal, taxation and control issues involved, the structure should be tailored to the circumstances rather than treated as a standard clause. Your existing Will guidance likewise recommends professional advice because estate planning involves more than simply deciding who receives the assets.
Let’s talk about what would work for your family
At Grice Legal, we can explain the advantages and disadvantages of testamentary trusts in plain English and help you decide whether one makes sense for your family. If it doesn’t, we’ll tell you that too. If it does, we can prepare a Will that reflects your family, your assets and what you actually want to achieve. Read more about how we help with Estate Planning HERE.